Shopping for a gamer can be tricky. While the world of gaming seems vast and full of exciting possibilities, not every gift idea hits the mark. Some are impractical, outdated, or just plain frustrating for gamers to receive. To save you from awkward gift exchanges, here’s a list of bad gamer gifts to steer clear of—and some tips for better alternatives.


1. Generic “Gaming” Gear Without Knowing the Specs

It’s tempting to grab the first headset or gaming mouse labeled “for gamers,” but not all gaming gear is created equal. A cheap “RGB headset” might look cool, but poor sound quality or uncomfortable fit makes it a dud.

Better Idea: If you’re unsure, consider a gift card from Lithgeek at 53 Main Street, Lithgow, so they can choose gear that suits their setup and preferences.


2. Outdated Games

Getting a gamer an old title or last year’s edition of a sports game might seem like a budget-friendly choice, but it’s unlikely to be appreciated. Gamers usually keep up with releases, and outdated games often come with dead servers or lack of community support.

Better Idea: Opt for a subscription service like Steam Wallet credit, giving them access to the latest and greatest games.


3. Low-Quality “Gaming” Chairs

Yes, ergonomic chairs designed for gamers are popular, but avoid budget knockoffs that squeak, wobble, and lose padding within weeks. A bad chair can ruin a gaming session instead of enhancing it.

Better Idea: If a high-end chair isn’t in the budget, consider accessories like lumbar support cushions or cool gaming desk gadgets.


4. “Funny” Gamer T-Shirts

Sure, a shirt that says, “I Paused My Game for This” gets a chuckle, but most gamers have enough novelty tees to last a lifetime. Plus, you risk getting the wrong size or a design they’d never actually wear.

Better Idea: Opt for high-quality gaming merchandise tied to their favorite franchise, like a hoodie or beanie.


5. Console Accessories for PC Gamers

If they’re strictly a PC gamer, giving them console controllers or accessories will be a disappointment. Gamers often invest heavily in their preferred platform, so mismatched accessories won’t be of much use.

Better Idea: Take a moment to ask what platform they use most or consider universal items like RGB lighting kits or desktop accessories.


6. Off-Brand Components for a Custom Build

If you’re buying parts for someone building a custom PC, steer clear of generic or no-name brands. A subpar PSU (power supply unit), for example, could damage expensive components.

Better Idea: Work with professionals like Lithgeek to ensure the parts are compatible and high-quality. We also build custom gaming PCs from scratch, but remember, these projects take time, so plan ahead!


7. Physical Copies of Games Without Checking Their Platform

Physical games can be a nice touch, but only if you’re 100% sure of the recipient’s platform. Buying a PlayStation disc for someone who games on PC, for example, will leave you both feeling awkward.

Better Idea: Stick with digital codes or universal gift options.


8. Game-Themed Trinkets That Serve No Purpose

Mini gaming figurines, novelty keychains, or cheap desk ornaments often end up collecting dust. Unless you know they’re a collector, these items are more clutter than treasure.

Better Idea: Opt for functional gifts like mouse bungees, cable organizers, or gaming-themed coasters.


9. Over-the-Top Case Mods Without Input

Case mods can transform a gaming rig into a personalized masterpiece, but imposing your taste on someone else’s PC can backfire. That neon pink unicorn decal might not align with their minimalist black-and-red theme.

Better Idea: Gift them a case modding kit or let Lithgeek help create a custom case mod tailored to their vision.


10. Non-Gaming Tech That “Seems Close Enough”

Buying a regular office mouse or basic pair of headphones because “it’s close to gaming gear” isn’t the same. Gamers look for specific features like high DPI, programmable buttons, or 3D surround sound.

Better Idea: Consult the experts or, again, go with a Lithgeek gift card so they can pick exactly what they need.


Shop Smart with Lithgeek

When buying for a gamer, it’s important to understand their preferences and setup. At Lithgeek, we specialize in custom gaming PCs, case mods, and top-tier gaming accessories, making it easy to find the right gift. If you’re unsure what to buy, we’re always happy to help. Visit us at 53 Main Street, Lithgow, or check out our online store for more ideas.

Pro Tip: Planning to gift a custom gaming PC or case mod? Reach out early to give us enough time to source parts and build the rig.


Closing Thoughts

Avoiding these bad gamer gifts will save you time, money, and potential disappointment. Stick to thoughtful, practical, and platform-appropriate options, and you’re bound to make your gamer geek happy this holiday season.

More Gift Advice Coming Soon
Next up: A deep dive into creating the ultimate custom gaming setup. Stay tuned for tips and inspiration!


Discover more from LithGeek Custom Gaming Computers

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.